Office REITs Take a Hit as Canadian Investment Bank Lowers Price Targets
Canadian REITs have been downgraded by a top investment bank, causing some experts to reexamine the role of traditional office space. The CIBC World Markets report cited market volatility as a reason for these actions, stating that the profitability and viability of office real estate may need to be questioned.
The CIBC report, which downgraded price targets for Allied Properties, Dream Office, Slate Office, and True North Commercial, highlighted the impact that working from home continues to have on the market. Although the pandemic has brought about hybrid workspaces, there is uncertainty about how this will affect the future of the real estate investment trusts that own this property class.
The Canadian analyst's report followed criticisms from some landlord CEOs who have been asking banks to bring employees back to the office, citing productivity issues. However, the head of Canada's largest bank, Dave McKay, stated last month that their company has moved to require employees to work in the office three to four days a week, and he believes that a slow return to office work is hurting productivity in the country.
As the hybrid work model seems here to stay, the future of traditional office spaces and the impact on REITs that own them is uncertain. The nuanced answer, according to Dean Wilkinson, real estate analyst with CIBC World Markets, is that the real estate market is in a state of flux, and conditions are evolving.
Reports of REITs' Demise Overhyped? American Bank Sees a Compelling Opportunity
As headlines about headwinds facing commercial real estate proliferate, is the market overlooking the compelling opportunity that REITs present? Recent reports from different analysts offer divergent views on the performance of Real Estate Investment Trusts.
On the one hand, S&P Global Ratings predicts that technology sector slowdown will curb demand for office space, leading office assets to underperform other real estate property types over the next two years. S&P Global Ratings estimates that the office REIT sector will experience relatively flat to slightly negative net operating income growth in 2023 due to slow leasing activity, giving landlords limited pricing power.
On the other hand, Raymond James, an American investment bank that tracks Canadian and American REITs, has a different take on the market. Raymond James issued a report last Friday titled "Fake News: Is Commercial Real Estate the Next Shoe to Drop? Disconnect Springs Compelling Opportunity for REITs."
In contrast to negative headlines, the Raymond James analysts found that office real estate only comprises about 15% of the 20-trillion-dollar commercial real estate market and less than 4% of REIT market cap. Therefore, they view the current REIT market as a compelling investment opportunity. The report cites several factors that support this assessment: REIT balance sheets are in good shape; REITs face minimal interest rate and refinancing risk; REIT development pipelines are well below pre-global financial crisis levels; strong liquidity profiles lower relative need for capital for completing projects; REITs still have access to capital; and opportunities for REIT consolidation are likely to emerge.
In Canada, concerns about the "purported demise" of the traditional office persist, according to CIBC World Markets' Jason Wilkinson, who noted that office REITs lagged behind the overall recovery of publicly traded REITs after the global financial crisis. The Canadian office vacancy rate stands at a record high of 17.7%, according to CBRE, a real estate brokerage.
So, which view should investors follow? The answer depends on how investors weigh the relative value of office properties in the overall commercial real estate universe and in different markets. Both S&P Global Ratings and Raymond James point to specific factors that affect the performance of office REITs and commercial real estate in general. The market is complex and dynamic, requiring careful analysis and monitoring.
In conclusion, recent reports provide different perspectives on the performance of office REITs and commercial real estate. Investors should recognize the risks and opportunities that the market offers and tailor their investments accordingly. Do not let the headlines alone dictate your strategy; consult with a professional advisor who can help you navigate the complexities of the real estate world.